Indeed that was me in the other thread on book managers, so to be fair people aren’t raving about it - only I am haha!

BookOrbit is doing pretty well for me so far with comics. Seems to have manga options about reverse reading direction.

Even better for books too. Can do koreader opds and email books as well. (I have a kobo so I haven’t tried the kindle-orientated email, but I assume it’s ez pz)

Very good metadata ingestion. And the book/comic libraries aren’t in different silo’d worlds like they are with Calibre and its derivatives.

I’m pretty pleased so far, have found some niggles but nothing bad. And the good stuff plenty outweighs anything else. It’s all ready to go, I switched libraries quickly. And it ate up my old library with its different (not as good) naming style and realigned it automatically, which was nice.

I have seent that in my searches [ https://github.com/naleo/audiobookshelf.koplugin ], but I decided to go for something that has it natively since sometimes the plugins get björked by updates (from my experience with gnome and its plugins)

But I will say, Audiobookshelf is superior for its purpose: audiobooks and podcasts. If I wanted that first I’d slap the plugin on to be happy with books/comics and kobos, but I wanted book/comics first so I chose a diff path - abs ain’t bad!

I’ve got BookOrbit and Audiobookshelf both going. They both can be hosted securely (locked down compose file with read-only, non-root user, etc.) and use Postgres as their DBs, both key features.

I added in BookOrbit to try since it has kobo sync and koreader sync that Audiobookshelf lacks.

I moved books from Audiobookshelf to get BookOrbit going and there was a learning curve to get the UI to do it optimally for me, but I eventually got it to work for me. BookOrbit has the ability to write metadata to the files themselves, which most things lack. Very nice for portability.

There’s a folder BookOrbit imports from and you can set it to populate metadata automatically - seems strongly built for an automated library system.

Both have been very stable. I’d say BookOrbit is the better one - and it supports audiobooks too. Audiobookshelf handles multiple libraries (like books and comics) in a clunky way (have to switch between them like they’re completely different silo’d libraries - much like how Calibre handles them). BookOrbit has them separated but easy to see they exist and you can mix and match them in a collection or something. Better way to handle it.

I use the desktop application Calibre to convert books as needed, but BookOrbit will automatically generate kobo epubs from epubs when syncing so I need not worry about kepub prep.

Lastly, I chose BookOrbit to try over others because Grimmory needs a ton of RAM, Kavita had features behind a paywall, some other one is comic-focused, and the Calibre web iterations give off the vibe of a lot of tapes the inside to make them work; I had big doubts Calibre Web Auto would be able to be run non-root and read-only. Chose Audiobookshelf originally because of the Calibre mess and other options didn’t exist or were much less established.

Edit: lore drop: BookOrbit is a feature copy of Booklore but written not in Java (I think JS), and Grimmory is a community fork of Booklore after its creator fell into AI psychosis.