You must log in or register to comment.
- 24 hours
Nobody talking about how this article seems very strongly AI-written? Like it offers things it can “do for you” at the end of each section. And the "what this means to you’ has nothing about what this means to you…
Very interesting.
- REDACTED@infosec.pubEnglish17 hours
The drop correlates with the time reddit locked down old reddit from accessing anonymously/without logging in to avoid AI scraping. Reddit themselves did this.
EDOT: And OpenAI also changed how the web search works; https://www.forbes.com/sites/gabrielalinzainescu/2026/08/20/reddit-nearly-vanishes-from-chatgpt-citations-after-openai-search-change/
- ThomasWilliams@lemmy.worldEnglish18 hours
It’s nothing to do with that. Reddit is blocking AI searches because it’s contract with OpenAI expired last month.
- REDACTED@infosec.pubEnglish17 hours
Correct me if I’m wrong, but contract has nothing to do with web searches. It was about training AIs, a data-licensing deal.
I learned more here, OpenAI themselves changed how the web search works; https://www.forbes.com/sites/gabrielalinzainescu/2026/08/20/reddit-nearly-vanishes-from-chatgpt-citations-after-openai-search-change/
- Squizzy@lemmy.worldEnglish17 hours
I used morphe on the reddit app and it is still unusable. You cant get r/all or even easily get to te shitty popular sub. It shows me days and weeks old stuff. Completely different experience to what I want reddit for, new links.
- Rug_Pisser@piefed.zipEnglish1 day
Even the normal Reddit site locks up after a few seconds if you’re not logged in. I’m still happy to kill time on msoutlookit while I’m at work, but follow any links to the main site and it locks you out pretty quickly. I imagine even that will be gone too soon.
1 dayHow much you wanna bet this lazy reporting from “promptwatch” is AI generated?
- im_fine_sandy@nord.pubEnglish1 day
OpenAI would not have been scraping old ui?
Also most reddit content has long since been injested. No need to visit your http site anymore
- REDACTED@infosec.pubEnglish1 day
They actually did use old reddit, as confirmed by reddit itself, as confirmed by massive drop after the change. It was simply far easier to scrape old reddit (pre-rendered instead of relying on JavaScript and dynamic content load)
- im_fine_sandy@nord.pubEnglish1 day
You seem to have misunderstood, and the article you linked doesn’t contradict what I’ve said.
Wealthy, sophisticated LLM developers would not have been scraping old reddit. They would pay reddit for API access.
Shutting down old reddit closes the door on back yard developers, not OpenAI.
Additionally, when you run a prompt in a chatbot, it doesn’t scurry away and scrape old reddit and then formulate an answer. The scraping of content is going on while the model is being developed.
As if wealthy people pay for stuff they could have for free. Literally everybody had their copyright infringed from the training of GenAI. Authors, Journalists, Artists, Musicians, Regisseurs, the list is endless. Unless you sue, you won’t see any compensation from them. By now you should know that companies only play fair if they’re forced to, otherwise literally anything goes.
It’s quite naive to believe they would pay for API access, tbh.
- REDACTED@infosec.pubEnglish1 day
Wealthy, sophisticated LLM developers would not have been scraping old reddit. They would pay reddit for API access.
Shutting down old reddit closes the door on back yard developers, not OpenAI.
And yet it did. And yet reddit mentioned shutting down API too
- magnue@lemmy.worldEnglish2 days
Imagine if the AI companies used their infinite money glitch to just replace Reddit instead. Now that’s karma.
- Nonconfrontational@lemmy.mlEnglish1 day
Surprised this fucking idiot used a source instead of strategically editing it out.
- Psythik@lemmy.worldEnglish5 hours
All major LLMs have had citation ability for while now. Any time I ask one a question I can’t find the answer to, if it’s not providing a source, I automatically assume the output is slop. And even then, you still have to be wary, because it will often make something up then cite a semi-related source that doesn’t actually contain its claims.
- boonhet@sopuli.xyzEnglish1 day
It’s had web search ability for about 2 years now. That makes it a fair bit more reliable than before except for when the source it finds is actually irrelevant. But if you’re knowledgeable in the domain you’re prompting about, it’ll usually be easy to figure out. If you’re not… Well, good luck.
I know it had web searchability, but it never provided the source of the information, which is, like, a giant fucking problem .
- TIEPilot@lemmy.worldEnglish2 days
While I’m not a fan of scrapping you would think reddit would want this to push traffic to the site. Get a good answer and follow the referral link and you have a new monkey.
- bugbear@lemmy.sdf.orgEnglish2 days
Are there any statistics on how many LLM chatbot users actually click on the source links?
- Aqivex@fedinsfw.appEnglish1 day
That’s just for Google’s AI summaries, but it’s the only one with actual methodology disclosed I could find on a quick (non-AI) search.
Plenty of SEO mills with their own “studies” too, and the trend is similar. People don’t interact with the source sites or if they do it’s extremely seldom.
They (SEO mills) are currently trying to flip the gaslight towards “Worry not dear Webmaster, now you just have to make sure your content is now formed so it’s engaging for AI search and engage able right from the AI!” type shit.
I’m tired boss, and I’m not even generally (as in, in all aspects) anti-AI. Yet, I guess.
- bugbear@lemmy.sdf.orgEnglish1 day
Ah yes, I’ve noticed lots of SEO consultant companies are trying to pivot into “we’ll help you to make AI scrape your website more so you show up in the AI search”.
I hadn’t seen the study before, thanks. That’s what I expected, honestly. I guess you could argue they are still building brand awareness, because people subconsciously note the brand as the source, but I don’t think that amounts to much.
- TIEPilot@lemmy.worldEnglish1 day
Great question, I wish I knew. I know when I’m on a deep dive I will hit the links as there is other information or other articles the scrapped site has.
- Ludicrous0251@piefed.zipEnglish1 day
I mean just about every metric I’ve seen suggests most websites that see an increase in scraping see a decrease in actual human visitors. I doubt there’s much distinction between chat and search users - the goal of these services is to drop click-through rates.
- bugbear@lemmy.sdf.orgEnglish1 day
Oh, definitely. They are reinventing the old portals concept. That’s why I don’t think Reddit actually wants to encourage the scraping (partly also because they sell data themselves to build LLM, but that’s another thing)
- 1 day
I don’t know how many do, but they’re fools if they don’t.
You’d think that since those links are there, that the information on those links matches what that LLM says, and thus not a hallucination, but at least twice, I’ve found the information straight up wasn’t there, or the LLM had misread / misinterpreted the page’s content.
But then I may not be a regular user. I ask a question maybe once every one to two weeks because a regular search finds nothing and, like I say, I prefer to check the sources.
- AA5B@lemmy.worldEnglish1 day
I do for things where I want to be accurate, but sometimes it seems like I’m the only one
On the other hand I advised my teen to buy the wrong battery because I didn’t click into the results for “what battery do i need to replace in my Subaru key?”
- BassTurd@lemmy.worldEnglish1 day
I think it had the opposite effect. I believe the recently didn’t renew their contract with Google because they were upset people weren’t coming to the site, just getting answers from Gemini. I could be wrong, but I thought I read that
- valkyre09@lemmy.worldEnglish1 day
The guys on LTT mentioned this during their Linux challenge, but I’ve found it to be true -
Scouring forums for answers to obscure errors used to take hours. Now I just throw it at Gemini, troubleshoot in real time and find the fix.
I’ve even started asking it to give me a PDF of the steps we took and filing them away for future me.
- AceBonobo@lemmy.worldEnglish1 day
I like to ask it for a beautiful html page instead of a pdf. PDFs are a pain later on.
- valkyre09@lemmy.worldEnglish1 day
Tonight I spent the time spinning up a silverbullet instance and converting the PDFs to .md files. You’re right, PDFs aren’t searchable and will be a pain as the database grows.
Thanks for sharing :)
